• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Consolidated Rock Holding Company

Consolidated Rock - Investment Holding Company of Sultan Ameerali

  • Overview
  • Services
  • Latest Posts
    • Investment Ideas
    • Notes and Concepts
  • Portfolio
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Repositioning the gold basket

June 1, 2021

I made some adjustments to my gold exposure to raise cash, reduce the number of stocks and take less portfolio-level and company-specific risk.

  • Sold Abitibi Royalties
  • Sold Eldorado Gold
  • Bought Osisko Gold Royalties
  • Sold Nomad Royalty warrants and closed position
  • Added to Nomad Royalty common
  • Closed short position in Ely Gold Royalties
  • Unchanged: Minera Alamos, Mako Mining (common and warrants), Sailfish Royalty, Orca Gold

Sold Abitibi Royalties, added Osisko Gold Royalties

This is a switch I’ve been wanting to make for a while. Osisko Gold Royalties and Abitibi Royalties both offer exposure to the Canadian Malartic mine, but I prefer the growth profile of Osisko and the plan put forward by Osisko Royalties CEO Sandeep Singh to earn back the trust of investors who loathed the Barkerville takeover. The hyper growth phase for Abitibi’s stock price is over and the prospect generation work it’s now financing makes me wonder how its business model differs from parent company Golden Valley Mines.

It won’t 5X in five years, but I expect to do very well with OR as the anchor of the basket and outperform Abitibi. Osisko Royalties isn’t supporting a functionally useless parent company. They also have the same capital allocation tools at their disposal, with more free cash flow and a better portfolio of growth assets.

Sold Eldorado Gold

I bought QMX Gold after the takeover announcement so I could back into Eldorado shares at a slight discount. My plan was to hold this position and generate some options income, but I think there will be a better and more obvious entry point later in the cycle. Eldorado is ripe for a hostile takeover once we get into the mania phase of the bull market, think Goldcorp’s bloated management structure with better assets. I also ran into a common problem for me – too many positions and the need to clean up my book. Better to book a small profit and bank that cash.

Nomad Royalties: Sold warrants and added common

I’ve botched this entire trade from the beginning. First I botched the warrant-clipping exercise, I couldn’t find much of a borrow on Nomad so I was mostly straight long …

I’m all about getting free stuff, so bought a large chunk of Coral Gold. Trading below the price of the cash + share offer from Nomad. The half warrant is essentially free. $CLH.V $NSR.TO

— Sultan Ameerali (@SultanAmeerali) September 14, 2020
The best laid plans …

When I ended up underwater after the deal closed and the other warrant clippers sold, I bought more instead of taking my lumps and joining them …

This started as a warrant-clipping exercise, but $NSR.TO has grown on me. Bulked up to a full position today.

– 25K GEOs in 2021
– 80% margins
– $1900 gold
– Clean balance sheet

I come up with CAD$48M in FCF and CAD$800M in equity value. Open to the possibility my math is wrong https://t.co/UyHT5UBr1I

— Sultan Ameerali (@SultanAmeerali) December 17, 2020
The market doesn’t care about your math, get out when the trade is moving against you

I still like my math and the long-term value of Nomad, but I am underwater on the stock for no good reason. However those free warrants have actually performed pretty well so I sold them between 29 and 23 cents to take myself off the clock and help reduce my cost base on the common shares. This isn’t a riskless position: Nomad is run by financial buyers in a competitive market for acquisitions. The possibility of NSR overpaying for growth is real. I like management and they are saying the right things, but this is the type of company you monitor on a transaction-by-transaction basis.

Closed out Ely short position

I don’t think anyone who follows me on Twitter is surprised I had a short position in Ely Gold Royalties. It’s been uninvestable since they gave Rick Rule a sweetheart deal – and the dilutive financings have kept coming. I was actually long Ely to start but eventually sold out, and then sold short, as I learned more about management and read every filing. The result of the long trade doesn’t justify bad process and lazy due diligence. If I published my rule book for investing in mining companies, one of the first chapters would be titled Sprott is not your friend.

Timing this short was relatively easy based on when Ely was doing marketing, news from Wallbridge Mining about Fenelon (Ely’s flagship royalty) and tracking warrant issuances.

Ely Gold is a time bomb of cheap paper waiting to explode. The royalties may do well. Eric Sprott will do better:
– Provided a LOC to $ELY.V secured by the company’s assets
– 10% rate with 2.5% standby fee on unused amounts
– 16.2 million “bonus warrants” issued at $0.37 https://t.co/W6k35sp43c

— Sultan Ameerali (@SultanAmeerali) September 26, 2020
This Tweet thread gets profane. Only click through if you aren’t the sensitive type.

I piled into the short in size in the $1.60 range and exited between 90 cents and current prices. If I was wrong and Ely started to recover I would have bailed out between $1.90 and $2. The overall package of assets is mediocre so the risk of a takeover was minimal.

I also had a small short position in Vox Royalty after they announced their financing with a warrant attached. But I couldn’t size the position properly and ended up closing out to trade for no gain when Vox bounced back into the $2.50 range without warning. Not the type of trade I’ll be making in future as it’s not worth the effort involved.

The current basket

Anchor position

  • Osisko Gold Royalties: Organic growth, share buybacks and potential for multiple expansion as management delivers, all underpinned by a long-life royalty on Canadian Malartic

Small cap growth stocks (looking for at least 5X in five years)

  • Mako Mining (common and warrants): Got in very early. Mispriced mine developer now heading for re-rating as it begins commercial production. Fully funded exploration program. Built to be sold by Wexford Capital.
  • Minera Alamos: Got in very early. Successful team of mine builders funded to production. Santana will be producing in weeks, which should allow MAI to self fund its other mine builds.
  • Nomad Royalty: Organic growth story. Maverix 2.0 in best-case scenario.

Special Situations

  • Sailfish Royalty: Backed in early through Terraco takeover. Worth at least 8X my cost base on a SOTP basis. Built to be sold by Wexford Capital.
  • Orca Gold: Stupid cheap on SOTP basis. Owns 31% of Montage Gold. Block 14 deposit in Sudan will eventually be sold to a Chinese buyer. Built to be sold by Ross Beaty.

Filed Under: Investment Ideas Tagged With: arbitrage, Gold, Royalties

Recent Posts

  • 2022 Portfolio review: A tribute to the Chaos Giraffe
  • 2022 Metals and Mining Year in Review
  • December purchases and useful links

Recent Tweets

Sultan Ameerali Follow

Investor. Marketing Expert. Don’t buy any stock because I mentioned it. Boxer, award-winning reporter, author in a different life. Ex-BNN, 680News, CTV News etc

SultanAmeerali
sultanameerali Sultan Ameerali @sultanameerali ·
16h

Seemed like the right book to pull off the shelf given the state of the world. Give me a few days and I’ll be able to spew uninformed bank hot takes with the best of them.

Reply on Twitter 1641487392946126849 Retweet on Twitter 1641487392946126849 Like on Twitter 1641487392946126849 2 Twitter 1641487392946126849
Retweet on Twitter Sultan Ameerali Retweeted
tristinhopper Tristin Hopper @tristinhopper ·
29 Mar

It's rather incredible that you can run up a $50 billion deficit amid relatively good economic times, and military, health care, housing and any number of other basic metrics remain a disaster, and will remain so into the future.

Reply on Twitter 1641174144313352193 Retweet on Twitter 1641174144313352193 138 Like on Twitter 1641174144313352193 686 Twitter 1641174144313352193
Retweet on Twitter Sultan Ameerali Retweeted
econguyrosie David Rosenberg @econguyrosie ·
28 Mar

Canada’s budget gets a big fat F. The tax bite expands. Spending out of control – an added $42bn in the next 5 yrs brings the cumulative burst since 2021 to $345bn! FY24 deficit’s to balloon to $40bn from last Fall’s estimate of $30.6bn and debt/GDP ratio up to 43.5% from 42.4%.

Reply on Twitter 1640828030355402753 Retweet on Twitter 1640828030355402753 387 Like on Twitter 1640828030355402753 1544 Twitter 1640828030355402753
sultanameerali Sultan Ameerali @sultanameerali ·
28 Mar

$SDE.TO is paying out $9.50/share. This was an easy buy at ~$4.50/share. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/spartan-delta-corp-announces-1-110000284.html

Reply on Twitter 1640697110298329088 Retweet on Twitter 1640697110298329088 Like on Twitter 1640697110298329088 1 Twitter 1640697110298329088
Retweet on Twitter Sultan Ameerali Retweeted
reuterscommods Reuters Energy and Commodities @reuterscommods ·
28 Mar

China's 2023 crude oil imports set for 6.2% rise, but risks prevail - column by @ClydeCommods https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/chinas-2023-crude-oil-imports-set-62-rise-risks-prevail-russell-2023-03-28/

Reply on Twitter 1640630049547091968 Retweet on Twitter 1640630049547091968 4 Like on Twitter 1640630049547091968 7 Twitter 1640630049547091968
Load More

Connect:

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

© 2021 Consolidated Rock Holding Company

  • Disclaimer
  • Amazon Associates Link
  • Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
  • Contact